skip to main | skip to sidebar

nayi taazi . . .

(which literally means 'new & fresh' in Hindi), as well as some phati-puraani (aka 'old and tattered') thoughts on just about everything I fancy!

Pages

  • Home

Saturday, February 19, 2011

India Calling

imagesThis is the title of a new book by Anand Giridharadas, an American author and son of immigrant Indian parents who grew up in Cleveland and worked in Mumbai for almost 6 years, first as a management consultant and then as a writer. He writes the “Currents” column for The New York Times and its global edition, the International Herald Tribune. This week, he gave a talk about his book at Harvard’s Humanities Center. It was followed by comments from Sugata Bose and Homi Bhabha, both well-known historians and faculty at Harvard. The talk was unusual in that it was held at lunch, which made it a little challenging for me to get out and attend. But I was keen on being there – whatever I had read about the book seemed very interesting and the Barker Humanities Center (where the talk was hosted) is a beautiful McKim Mead & White designed building that was even more beautifully restored by my firm a few years back. 

Anyways, so the talk…It began with Anand giving a bit of an insight into his relationship with his subject – contemporary India. A remark he made particularly struck me- he said that as a child born to immigrant parents in the US, his first introduction to India was a country that his parents left. It unconsciously implied for him that there was something that was worth leaving. While it was not intentional, many of his parents’ references to India recounted how life had been somewhat limiting in India and liberating in the US. His mother would often narrate how she could not dress in a certain way in India but could do so half way across the globe in Ohio. His childhood visits to India somewhat ratified his parents’ accounts. When he made a decision to live and work in Mumbai as an adult in 2003, the India that welcomed him posed a strikingly different picture. It was this shock that prompted him to write the book. He made it clear at the outset though, that the book is not about the technological and economic revolution that has taken place in India. Rather it is about the cultural changes that are rampant in Indian society yet are rarely talked about. The first major change that he identified was a greater emphasis on the ‘self’. Many personal decisions such as career, marriage, place of residence etc. that were once taken to appease family members, were now based largely, if not solely on personal happiness. While rapidly embracing lifestyles of their western counterparts, the Indian youth were different in that they lived comfortably within ‘simultaneous truths’. They lived in the ‘both/and’ rather than the ‘either/or’ world. While they partied, smoked and doped their way into the evening, they still found time (and sobriety) to have dinner with their grandparents at night. The book chapters are organized under headings like : Love, Anger, Ambition..and so on.  He talked briefly about anecdotes in the book – there is a story of a poor kid from a village who was able to make it big in Mumbai. He counted his conversation with a school principal about the usual complaint that Indian kids are not creative thinkers and are unable to think out-of-the-box. The response he received was that parents and their over-protective attitudes (born out of love) are to blame - the culture of Don’t do this! Don’t go there! breeds compliance and kills ingenuity amongst kids. Under Anger, his book talks about the Naxalite insurgency. There is also an extended interview with Mukesh Ambani.

Anand’s talk was followed by comments from Sugata Bose. After briefly praising the book for tackling an overwhelming subject, Prof. Bose proceeded with some critical remarks. The first being that Anand’s story of India is really the story of Urban India –and not the vast majority of the country which is still primarily rural and agrarian. He asked – where are the stories of farmers’ suicides and the abject poverty of tribals? He asked why there was not a chapter titled ‘Greed’ that talked about the gargantuan scale of corruption that has pervaded every aspect of contemporary Indian life. He also proposed that the ideas of ‘self’ and ‘social equality’ are not imports of the West or ideas that the Indian Maoists have borrowed from China, rather their roots can be found in Indian culture itself—in the texts of Kalidasa and Mahabharata.

I had to leave early so couldn’t stay till the end. Also I haven’t yet read the book. Nonetheless, I thought the talk was very interesting. I agree that Anand’s book seemed biased towards urban India, but I agree with the explanation he gave later, that the subject is so vast he chose to tackle it as a ‘sliver’ of society. He wrote about the cultural changes that he observed living in Mumbai & while he did make an attempt to cover the hinterland, the reach was decidedly limited. Also while Prof. Bose’s comments may be right that historic Indian texts are rife with concepts of reconciling the ‘self’ with ‘society’ and notions of equality etc. their connection with contemporary India is unarguably and unfortunately broken. This is perhaps why the Indian youth turn to seemingly radical ideas from elsewhere around the globe, instead of reaching in-house to our rich past.

Posted by Unknown at 6:41 PM 3 comments Email This BlogThis! Share to X Share to Facebook
Labels: Event Review, India

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Shantaram

The novel came out quite a while back – I read great reviews everywhere – was super-intrigued by the plot, its author and the unusual story behind the book. Yet, somehow I never got around to reading it. Tried to borrow it from the public library a couple of times – but all copies had never-ending queues. Well, finally the public interest faded and I got my hands on a pretty worn and battered copy a few weeks back. And am I glad I finally read it!
image
Shantaram is definitely one of my favorite books from now on. From the minute I started reading it, I was taken by the remarkable story telling of Gregory David Roberts. The best way I can describe the book is that it is so ‘vivid’ – each location, each character and each sub-plot feels so alive and real. While, of course, this can be attributed to the fact many events actually happened in the author’s life, yet the skill with which he tells their story and fuses it with figments of his imagination is truly commendable. The book takes its readers on a journey of emotions that juggle between suspense, empathy, joy, sorrow and just plain old interest in how the story unfolds.  I have to admit I enjoyed the first half or two-thirds of the book more than the rest. It is very unusual that I jot down lines that I like from a book I’m reading – too lazy to pause and make the effort! Yet, this time around, I felt compelled to do so- I wanted to be able to read them over again. And so I diligently managed to do that for almost two-thirds of the book and then the laziness-effort-part and the anxiety to finish reading took over.

I visited the author’s website a couple of days back and learnt about how this was slated to be a big movie production with Johnny Depp in the lead. But seems like all plans fell through. Anyways, it would have been a mammoth task to represent it all in a 2-3 hour movie.

Logging off for now & hoping to be more regular with blogging! Btw, my favorite character in the book was Prabhaker and the most annoying was Karla.
Posted by Unknown at 10:26 PM 0 comments Email This BlogThis! Share to X Share to Facebook
Labels: Book Review, India
Newer Posts Older Posts Home

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile

Subscribe via email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Labels

  • Book Review (1)
  • Event Review (1)
  • General (7)
  • hiking (3)
  • India (3)
  • Marathon (5)
  • preservation (1)
  • Travel (3)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2011 (4)
    • ►  March (1)
    • ▼  February (2)
      • India Calling
      • Shantaram
    • ►  January (1)
  • ►  2010 (9)
    • ►  August (3)
    • ►  March (1)
    • ►  February (3)
    • ►  January (2)
  • ►  2009 (12)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (1)
    • ►  July (2)
    • ►  March (2)
    • ►  February (3)

Subscribe To

Posts
Atom
Posts
All Comments
Atom
All Comments

My Blog List

  • Design*Sponge
    Discover the Secrets of Making Money From Your Art - Making money from your art is largely about talent. You will need to produce art which is beautiful enough or unique enough to be coveted by others. As wel...
    6 years ago
  • The Storque
    Swoon-Worthy Valentine’s Day Gifts From Black-Owned Etsy Shops - [image: Etsy.com handmade and vintage goods] Photo by Boutique de Bandeaux As February 14th inches closer on the calendar, the countdown to Cupid’s day ...
    7 years ago

Followers

Powered by Blogger.
 
Copyright (c) 2010 nayi taazi . . .. Designed for Video Games
Download Christmas photos, Public Liability Insurance, Premium Themes